Federal IDR volume has far exceeded original projections, and the costs have drawn attention from payers, employers and lawmakers. For provider organizations planning 2027 and 2028, the question is no longer only how to win disputes, but how durable the process is and how to use it strategically.

Courts: insurer challenges to awards

Insurers have filed lawsuits alleging that IDR filers abused the process. In April 2026, a federal court in California dismissed Anthem's claims to vacate awards won by HaloMD, and a federal court in Florida dismissed Aetna's suit against Radiology Partners with prejudice, finding Aetna should have raised its objections during the IDR process. These rulings make administrative participation, including eligibility objections, the main place to contest a dispute. Appeals and other cases continue.

Congress: two competing directions

ProposalWhat it would doStatus
Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act (Rep. Pallone, introduced October 2026)End Federal IDR for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028; set out-of-network payment at a recalculated QPA based on median contracted rates; require payment within 30 daysIntroduced; supported by consumer and labor groups, opposed by physician groups
No Surprises Act Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710 / S. 2420)Add penalties for late or unpaid IDR awards and strengthen enforcementIntroduced July 2025; supported by physician groups

Neither bill has been enacted. Track both, because they point in opposite directions for out-of-network revenue.

The QPA in flux

The en banc Fifth Circuit's TMA III decision invalidated parts of the QPA methodology, and the government has asked the Supreme Court to limit the remedy rather than revisit the QPA holdings. Recalculated QPAs could narrow the gap between initial payments and awards. See our TMA III analysis.

Cost pressure and its effects

Analysts have estimated the IDR process has added more than $22 billion in costs, and reporting on 2025 data puts provider awards at nearly $15 billion that year. Payers cite these figures in rate filings and lobbying. Providers point to understated QPAs and slow, incomplete payment of awards. Expect continued pressure on both sides, and possible further rulemaking.

Strategy for 2027

  1. Keep filing disciplined: eligibility scrubbing and clean batches protect your credibility and your results.
  2. Use your determination history in contract talks: a documented record of awards for a payer is evidence for in-network rate proposals.
  3. Model a no-IDR scenario: estimate revenue if out-of-network payment defaulted to the QPA from 2028.
  4. Strengthen collections: escalate unpaid awards on day 31 and reserve realistically.
  5. Watch the docket and Congress monthly, and update assumptions quarterly.

Our compliance checklist and unpaid awards guide cover the operational side.

Scenario planning

ScenarioWhat changesProvider response
Status quoIDR continues under the 2026 rulesKeep improving eligibility, batching and collections
Enforcement legislation passesPenalties and interest for late awardsFaster cash; lower reserves for unpaid awards
IDR replaced by a QPA-based standard from 2028Out-of-network payment set by a formulaShift effort to contracting and network participation
Supreme Court narrows the TMA III remedyRecalculated QPAs may apply more narrowlyRe-check QPAs by plan and region

Using IDR data in contracting

  1. Summarize determinations by payer, service and region.
  2. Calculate the average determined amount relative to the payer's initial payments.
  3. Show the administrative cost the payer incurs in disputes with you.
  4. Propose in-network rates that reflect market value and reduce disputes on both sides.
  5. Track whether new contracts reduce dispute volume and improve cash flow.

Signals to watch in 2027

  • CMS announcements activating the federal IDR registry and portal-based open negotiation.
  • Supreme Court action on the TMA III petition.
  • Committee activity on the Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act and the No Surprises Act Enforcement Act.
  • Appellate decisions on enforcing awards and on insurer challenges to IDR filers.
  • New CMS public use file releases and dispute volume trends.
Official Government Authority
Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act announcement
Authority: House Energy and Commerce Committee Democrats
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
No Surprises Act Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710)
Authority: U.S. Government Publishing Office
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
Federal IDR Operations Final Rule (91 FR 33900)
Authority: Federal Register
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)

Frequently Addressed Procedural Questions

Is Federal IDR being eliminated?
Not under current law. A bill introduced in October 2026 would end IDR for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028, but it has not been enacted.
Have insurers succeeded in overturning IDR awards in court?
In April 2026, federal courts dismissed Anthem's case against HaloMD and Aetna's case against Radiology Partners. Other cases and appeals continue.
How can providers use IDR results in contracting?
A documented history of determinations for a payer supports in-network rate proposals and shows what out-of-network payment has looked like.
What should providers plan for?
Run today's process carefully, strengthen award collections, and model a scenario in which IDR is replaced by a QPA-based payment standard.
When would a QPA-based payment standard start under the Pallone bill?
For items and services furnished on or after January 1, 2028, if the bill were enacted as introduced.
Should providers change strategy now?
Keep running the current process carefully, and use IDR results to strengthen contract negotiations, which helps under every scenario.