Winning a determination is not the same as being paid. Physician organizations have reported that a meaningful share of awards arrive late, short or not at all; an emergency medicine practice survey cited by the AMA found that about a quarter of respondents reported awards unpaid or paid incorrectly within the required time. The 2026 final rule did not add a new federal penalty for late payment, so a disciplined escalation process is now essential.
Where the courts stand
| Court | Case | Holding |
|---|---|---|
| Fifth Circuit (2025) | Guardian Flight v. Health Care Service Corp. | No private right of action to enforce IDR awards; the Supreme Court declined to hear the case in 2026 |
| Second Circuit (September 17, 2026) | East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna | Joined the Fifth Circuit; a provider with more than $3 million in unpaid awards had no private right of action and was left with administrative remedies |
Some district courts elsewhere have reached different conclusions, and related questions are on appeal in other circuits. The Second Circuit did not decide every possible legal theory for recovering an unpaid award. Talk to counsel before choosing a litigation route.
The day-31 escalation process
| Plan type | Where to escalate |
|---|---|
| Any plan subject to the No Surprises Act | File a complaint with the CMS No Surprises Help Desk with the determination, due date and payment record |
| Fully insured plan | Also the state insurance department in the plan's state |
| Self-funded ERISA plan | Also the Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration |
| State or local government plan | CMS, which enforces the requirements for these plans |
The escalation packet
- The written payment determination and dispute number.
- The date the determination was issued and the 30-calendar-day due date.
- Your payment ledger showing nothing or a short amount received.
- Copies of follow-up requests sent to the plan, with dates.
- Plan identification, including funding status where known.
Legislation to watch
The bipartisan No Surprises Act Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710 / S. 2420), introduced in July 2025, would authorize penalties for plans that miss the payment deadline after a binding determination, including penalties tied to the unpaid amount plus interest, and would strengthen federal enforcement. Physician groups support it; some employer and labor groups oppose it. Track its status, and see our 2027 outlook for competing proposals.
A payer payment-performance dashboard
| Metric | Calculation |
|---|---|
| On-time payment rate | Awards paid in full within 30 calendar days ÷ awards due |
| Short-pay rate | Awards paid below the determined amount ÷ awards paid |
| Days to payment | Median days from determination to payment |
| Unpaid balance | Total determined amounts not yet received, by age |
A follow-up cadence
- Day 31: send a written request to the plan citing the determination and due date.
- Day 31: file the CMS complaint and, where applicable, the state or Department of Labor complaint.
- Day 45: follow up with the plan and the regulator; record responses.
- Day 60: escalate internally to finance and leadership; consider counsel for large balances.
- Monthly: report unpaid awards by payer to leadership.
Accounting considerations
How to record determined but unpaid awards is a question for your accountant. Many organizations recognize expected collections net of a reserve informed by each payer's payment history, and revisit the reserve as payments arrive. Keep the documentation that supports the reserve, because auditors will ask.
Using payment performance in negotiations
A documented history of late or missing award payments is relevant in contract negotiations and regulatory complaints. Share it with payer relations teams, and use it when deciding where to focus dispute effort.
