The QPA is the plan's benchmark for out-of-network payment and the number every offer is measured against. When the method that produces it is flawed, the QPAs on your remittances are understated, and your open negotiation and offer strategy start from the wrong anchor. This article explains what changed and how to audit.

The TMA cases in brief

The Texas Medical Association and other providers brought a series of challenges to the No Surprises Act rules. Earlier cases removed a regulatory presumption in favor of the QPA in arbitration and struck down other provisions. TMA III challenged the QPA calculation method itself. A Fifth Circuit panel upheld most of the method in 2024; the full court reheard the case and largely reversed.

What the en banc court decided

IssueHoldingPractical effect
Ghost rates in the QPAUnlawfulContracted rates for services a provider never performs should not pull the median down.
Excluding bonus and incentive paymentsUnlawfulPayments such as incentive or risk-sharing amounts should not be ignored when computing contracted rates.
Excluding single-case agreementsUpheldOne-off agreements can still be excluded from the QPA.

Commentators expect the decision to raise QPAs as plans recalculate. The court's mandate issued October 2, 2026.

What the Supreme Court petition does and does not ask

The government's petition asks whether the Administrative Procedure Act allows courts to vacate a rule universally, rather than only as to the parties. It does not ask the Court to review whether the QPA rules were lawful. If the Court takes the case and narrows the remedy, the practical reach of the decision could change; until then, treat the QPA holdings as the governing reading in the Fifth Circuit's decision and watch the docket.

Four QPA audit actions

  1. Inventory open disputes and recent remittances where the QPA looks low for the service and region.
  2. Request the QPA information plans must provide on request under 45 C.F.R. §149.140(d), including how the QPA was determined.
  3. Check the new initial payment disclosures required by the 2026 final rule, such as the plan's legal name.
  4. Build offers on affirmative evidence about the service, the provider and the market, and use a documented QPA problem as context rather than the whole argument.

Balanced context

Payers and providers read IDR data differently. Providers point to high provider win rates and awards above the QPA as signs of depressed QPAs. Payers and some researchers argue awards also run well above typical in-network rates. A strong offer does not depend on winning that debate; it depends on evidence the entity is allowed to weigh. See our offer packet guide and the existing QPA disclosure audit.

How the QPA is supposed to work

The QPA is generally the plan's median contracted rate for the same or similar service, by a provider in the same or similar specialty, in the same geographic region, based on 2019 rates indexed forward. Because it is a median of contracted rates, the inputs matter: which contracts are included and what payments count as part of a contracted rate. TMA III addressed exactly those inputs.

Why ghost rates pull QPAs down

Many provider contracts include a full fee schedule, even for services the provider never performs. Counting those rates in the median adds data points that do not reflect real payments for the service, which can lower the QPA. The en banc court held that including them was inconsistent with the statute.

A QPA information request template

Use language like the following, adapted with counsel's input, when asking a plan for the information it must provide on request:

Tracking recalculations

  • Record the QPA on each remittance and the date received.
  • Compare QPAs for the same service and plan before and after recalculation.
  • Flag plans that have not changed QPAs for services where you expect an effect.
  • Use the history in open negotiation and offers.
Official Government Authority
45 C.F.R. §149.140 — Qualifying Payment Amount Methodology
Authority: Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
Texas Medical Association v. HHS, Supreme Court Docket No. 26-491
Authority: Supreme Court of the United States
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)

Frequently Addressed Procedural Questions

What are ghost rates?
Contracted rates for services that a provider does not actually furnish. The en banc Fifth Circuit held that including them in the QPA calculation was unlawful.
Did the Supreme Court petition challenge the QPA holdings?
No. The government's petition asks about the scope of the remedy, universal vacatur, not whether the QPA rules were lawful.
Will QPAs go up?
Commentators expect QPAs to rise as plans recalculate to remove ghost rates and include incentive payments. Timing varies by plan.
What should providers do now?
Audit low QPAs, request the plan's QPA information under 45 C.F.R. §149.140(d), and build offers on evidence the IDR entity may consider.
Does TMA III change past IDR determinations?
The decision addresses the QPA rules going forward; whether past determinations can be revisited is a separate legal question. Consult counsel.
Does a higher QPA mean higher awards?
Not automatically. The QPA is one factor; entities also weigh additional circumstances. A more accurate QPA can narrow the gap between initial payments and offers.