A strong offer is a number the entity can justify choosing. Overreaching with an unsupported figure hands the decision to the plan, because the entity cannot split the difference. This guide maps the allowed factors to concrete evidence and lists what to leave out.

Permitted factors and the evidence behind them

FactorEvidence that supports it
Qualifying payment amountThe remittance QPA, any QPA disclosures, and documented reasons it may be understated
Level of training, experience and quality and outcomes measurementsBoard certification, fellowship training, years in practice, and recognized quality measures relevant to the service
Market share of the provider or plan in the regionCredible data on market concentration for the specialty and region
Acuity of the patient or complexity of the serviceConcise clinical summary: severity, comorbidities, complications, time and resources, without excess patient information
Teaching status, case mix and scope of services (facilities)Facility designation, case mix data and service availability, such as 24/7 coverage
Good-faith efforts to contract, and prior contracted ratesProposals, negotiation correspondence, and contracted rates with the plan during the previous four plan years

Evidence the entity must not consider

  • Usual and customary charges.
  • The amount the provider would have billed, its billed charges or chargemaster rates.
  • Payment rates under Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP or TRICARE, including multiples of those rates.

A one-page offer narrative

  1. Eligibility statement: one sentence confirming the dispute meets the requirements.
  2. The number: the offer, and how it relates to the QPA.
  3. Why the QPA understates the value: specific, documented points.
  4. Factor evidence: the two or three strongest permitted factors, each tied to an exhibit.
  5. Exhibit index: every attachment named and numbered.

The offer window

Offers and both fees are due within 10 business days of entity selection. Under the 2026 final rule, an offer is treated as not received if required fees are unpaid, which hands the decision to the other party. Assign the offer and the fee payment to named people on day 1, not day 9.

  • Build a library of reusable exhibits: credentials, quality data and contracting history.
  • Keep clinical summaries short and free of unnecessary identifiers.
  • Have a second person check the number and the exhibit references before submission.
  • Save the submission confirmation and fee receipts in the case file.

Specialty and payer patterns

Specialties carry different evidence. Emergency medicine relies heavily on acuity, anesthesia on time and complexity, and air ambulance on its own factor list. See our playbooks for emergency medicine and radiology, anesthesiology and pathology and ambulance services, and our guide to QPA audits after TMA III.

An illustrative narrative outline

  1. "This dispute concerns [service] furnished on [date]; it meets the requirements for the Federal IDR process."
  2. "Our offer is $[amount]. The plan's QPA of $[amount] does not reflect [specific reason supported by exhibit]."
  3. "The patient presented with [acuity summary], requiring [resources], documented in Exhibit 2."
  4. "Our physician is [credential], with [relevant quality measure], documented in Exhibit 3."
  5. "Our contracting history with this plan, including [rates or proposals], is documented in Exhibit 4."

Building an exhibit library

Exhibit typeRefresh cycleOwner
Credentials and board certificationsAnnually or when changedCredentialing
Quality and outcome measuresEach reporting periodQuality team
Contracting history by planAfter each negotiationPayer relations
Market share analysisAnnuallyFinance or analytics
Facility characteristicsAnnuallyAdministration

Quality control before submission

  • The offer amount matches the narrative and the form.
  • Every exhibit cited exists and is labeled.
  • No prohibited evidence appears anywhere in the packet.
  • Patient information is limited to what supports acuity or complexity.
  • Both fees are paid and receipts saved.

After the determination

Record the outcome, the amount, the entity and the factors cited. Over time this shows which arguments work for which payers and services, and it feeds both your offer strategy and payer contracting. If the plan does not pay within 30 calendar days, follow our unpaid awards process.

Official Government Authority
45 C.F.R. §149.510 — Federal IDR Process
Authority: Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
45 C.F.R. §149.520 — Air Ambulance IDR
Authority: Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
Federal IDR Operations Final Rule (91 FR 33900)
Authority: Federal Register
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)

Frequently Addressed Procedural Questions

What is baseball-style arbitration?
Each party submits an offer and the certified IDR entity must select one of them. It cannot choose an amount in between.
What evidence can't a certified IDR entity consider?
Usual and customary charges, billed charges, and payment rates under Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and TRICARE.
When are offers due?
Within 10 business days of selecting the certified IDR entity, together with payment of the required fees.
Should the offer include the full medical record?
No. Provide a concise clinical summary that supports acuity or complexity, avoiding unnecessary patient information.
Can we reuse an offer narrative across disputes?
Reuse the structure and exhibits, but tailor the acuity and QPA points to each dispute.
Should the offer be as high as possible?
No. The entity must pick one offer, so an unsupported high offer makes the plan's offer more likely to be chosen.