Plain-language overview
Bifurcated. Fully insured plans issued in Virginia, the state employee plan and opted-in self-funded plans use SCC Bureau of Insurance arbitration under Va. Code 38.2-3445.01 and 38.2-3445.02. Other plans and air ambulance use federal IDR.
Start with plan jurisdiction, not the provider's location alone. Fully insured coverage may be governed by a specified state process, while self-funded employer plans commonly remain in the Federal Independent Dispute Resolution process. Confirm eligibility from the remittance, plan information, applicable state law, and current federal guidance before opening a dispute.
Which process applies in Virginia?
State Regulated Coverage
The SCC lists fully insured managed care plans issued in Virginia (including Marketplace plans), the Virginia state employee health plan, and opted-in self-funded plans. The statute covers emergency services and non-emergency surgical or ancillary services by an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility.
Self Funded Coverage
A self-funded plan must apply online to the Bureau at least 30 days before its effective date, which must be January 1 or the first day of the plan year. The Bureau keeps a searchable list. CMS's chart names Virginia as one of six states allowing this opt-in.
Air Ambulance And Federal Scope
Air ambulance claims, and self-funded plans that have not opted in, use federal IDR. The Virginia statute does not list air ambulance among the covered services.
Open negotiation requirements
State Process
Under 38.2-3445.01(F) the carrier must offer a commercially reasonable payment within 30 calendar days of a clean claim. A provider that disagrees must notify the carrier within 30 calendar days of payment, and both sides then negotiate in good faith for 30 calendar days.
Federal Process
For federal-track claims, 45 CFR 149.510 sets 30 business days of open negotiation and a 4-business-day filing window.
Federal and state IDR procedure
State Dispute Forum
Either party emails the Notice of Intent to Arbitrate form to BBVA@scc.virginia.gov and to the other party within 10 days after negotiation ends, stating its final offer. The Bureau supplies a list of approved arbitrators, and the parties split costs under the Commission's fee schedule.
Federal Dispute Forum
Federal-track claims are filed at nsa-idr.cms.gov, the CMS IDR Gateway.
Decision Model
The arbitrator must order payment of one side's final offer, weighing each side's evidence and methodology and the patient and case complexity. A Commission data set of commercial claims may be used. A party that misses a submission deadline can be ordered to pay the other side's final offer.
No Surprises Act and IDR deadlines
Confirm the trigger event and live rule before filing.
Carrier payment offer
30 calendar days from a clean claim
Provider dispute notice
30 calendar days from payment or payment notice
Good-faith negotiation
30 calendar days
Notice of intent to arbitrate
Within 10 calendar days after negotiation ends
Other side's final offer
30 calendar days after the notice
Arbitrator list and selection
List within 7 days; selection done within 20 days of the list
Written submissions and decision
Submissions 30 days after selection; decision 30 days after submissions
Nondisclosure agreement
Within 10 business days of the notice
Documentation checklist
- Written dispute notice to the carrier within 30 calendar days of payment
- Notice of Intent to Arbitrate form, emailed to BBVA@scc.virginia.gov and the other party
- Final offer amount stated in the notice
- Written submission with evidence and methodology showing that the offer is commercially reasonable
- Executed nondisclosure agreement
- Arbitrator Decision Reporting Form, filed by the arbitrator
Responsible agencies
- Virginia State Corporation Commission, Bureau of InsuranceState balance-billing arbitration and complaints
- CMS federal IDR GatewayFederal IDR process and No Surprises Act enforcement
Primary recovery and regulatory sources
- Va. Code 38.2-3445.01 Balance billing for certain services; prohibitedVirginia General Assembly (LIS)
- Va. Code 38.2-3445.02 ArbitrationVirginia General Assembly (LIS)
- Balance Billing (life and health companies)Virginia State Corporation Commission, Bureau of Insurance
- CMS chart: federal IDR applicability by stateCMS / CCIIO · 2023-01-11
This operational reference is educational, is not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.