Plain-language overview

New York runs its own IDR through DFS for insured plans; self-funded plans and air ambulance use Federal IDR.

Start with plan jurisdiction, not the provider's location alone. Fully insured coverage may be governed by a specified state process, while self-funded employer plans commonly remain in the Federal Independent Dispute Resolution process. Confirm eligibility from the remittance, plan information, applicable state law, and current federal guidance before opening a dispute.

Which process applies in New York?

State Regulated Coverage

DFS lists fully insured plans, the New York State Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan as subject to New York's process. CMS's letter ties it to nonparticipating physicians at hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers and to nonparticipating emergency facilities. DFS's provider form says Medicaid Managed Care disputes stopped being eligible on May 28, 2026.

Self Funded Coverage

DFS's surprise bill page says people whose employer or union self-funds their coverage are protected by the federal No Surprises Act rather than New York law, so those disputes go to Federal IDR. Empire Plan and Student Employee Health Plan members keep New York protections.

Air Ambulance And Federal Scope

CMS's letter applies Federal IDR under 45 CFR 149.520 to air ambulance services in insured New York coverage, and says DFS will enforce the outcome. It also applies Federal IDR to insured items and services that Article 6 and 23 NYCRR 400 do not reach.

State Surprise Billing Law

CMS lists Financial Services Law Article 6 and 23 NYCRR 400 as specified state laws. DFS Circular Letter 2 (2023) says the eightieth percentile of charges is one of seven equal-weight factors for physician services, alongside the plan's median in-network rate. It is not a fixed benchmark.

Open negotiation requirements

State Process

The DFS provider form lists one pre-filing step: a hospital that was previously in-network must attest that it sent a final offer to the other party at least 15 days before submitting to the IDRE.

Federal Process

New York follows the federal notice, negotiation, IDR order.

Federal and state IDR procedure

State Dispute Forum

Providers get a file number from DFS (the DFS Portal lists Independent Dispute Resolution), complete the IDR Provider and Insurer Application, pay the IDRE's full fee and send the application to the assigned IDRE. The IDRE refunds the prevailing party within 30 days of its determination, prorated for split decisions or settlements.

Federal Dispute Forum

Self-funded and air ambulance claims are filed in the CMS Federal IDR portal. Complaints about state-regulated plans go to DFS at dfs.ny.gov/complaint.

Decision Model

DFS says the IDRE chooses either the provider's bill or the health plan's payment, and the review is binding but admissible in court. Timing differs by source: DFS's consumer page says 45 business days from receipt of all information; Circular Letter 2 (2023) says 30 business days from receipt of the dispute.

No Surprises Act and IDR deadlines

Confirm the trigger event and live rule before filing.

  1. New York IDR application (provider)

    Within three years of the plan's initial payment

  2. Final offer by previously in-network hospital

    At least 15 days before submission to the IDRE

  3. IDRE determination

    45 business days after all information is received (DFS consumer page); 30 business days after receipt of the dispute (Circular Letter 2, 2023)

  4. Open negotiation notice, Federal IDR claims in New York

    Within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial

  5. Open negotiation period (New York)

    30 business days

  6. Federal IDR initiation (New York)

    4-business-day window after negotiation ends

Documentation checklist

  • DFS IDR file number
  • IDR Provider and Insurer Application
  • IDRE's full fee paid with the application
  • Remittance showing the initial payment or denial
  • Fee evidence: usual charge, training, experience, case facts

Responsible agencies

Primary recovery and regulatory sources

  1. DFS: Independent dispute resolution for providersNew York State Department of Financial Services · 2026
  2. DFS: Surprise medical billsNew York State Department of Financial Services · 2026
  3. DFS Insurance Circular Letter No. 2 (2023)New York State Department of Financial Services · 2023
  4. CMS letter to New York: CAA enforcementCMS / CCIIO
  5. 45 CFR 149.510, Federal IDR processeCFR / HHS · 2026

This operational reference is educational, is not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Related forms and official resources

Common questions

Does New York use state surprise-billing arbitration or Federal IDR?
For insured coverage, New York disputes go to a DFS-assigned independent dispute resolution entity under Financial Services Law Article 6 and 23 NYCRR 400, not Federal IDR. DFS says employer and union self-funded plans are outside New York's law, and CMS sends air ambulance services to Federal IDR.
What No Surprises Act and IDR deadlines should providers track in New York?
New York IDR application (provider): Within three years of the plan's initial payment; Final offer by previously in-network hospital: At least 15 days before submission to the IDRE; IDRE determination: 45 business days after all information is received (DFS consumer page); 30 business days after receipt of the dispute (Circular Letter 2, 2023). Verify the trigger date, current agency notices, and any extension before acting.
Which agencies administer these rules in New York?
The guide identifies New York State Department of Financial Services, New York State Department of Financial Services, CMS No Surprises Help Desk (1-800-985-3059). The correct agency depends on the plan and claim jurisdiction.