Plain-language overview
Bifurcated under CMS's July 20, 2023 revised enforcement letter. DIFS calculates reviews and limited complicating-factor arbitration serve specified state-law claims; federal IDR is available for eligible claims outside Michigan's state rate method.
Start with plan jurisdiction, not the provider's location alone. Fully insured coverage may be governed by a specified state process, while self-funded employer plans commonly remain in the Federal Independent Dispute Resolution process. Confirm eligibility from the remittance, plan information, applicable state law, and current federal guidance before opening a dispute.
Which process applies in Michigan?
State Regulated Coverage
CMS's revised July 20, 2023 letter identifies specified Michigan state laws for out-of-network payment amounts under certain insurance coverage. DIFS administers the Public Act 234 calculation-review and complicating-factor arbitration tracks. Verify the benefit plan's jurisdiction before assigning the forum.
Self Funded Coverage
CMS's revised letter applies Michigan's specified state laws to services furnished under insured group health plans and group or individual health insurance coverage. Self-funded plans are not within that description, so confirm the plan type before choosing a forum.
Air Ambulance And Federal Scope
CMS's revised July 2023 letter separates claims using Michigan's specified state laws from claims needing federal IDR. DIFS's state process addresses specified nonparticipating providers; the applicable air-ambulance and private self-funded plan route must be assessed separately under federal eligibility rules.
Open negotiation requirements
State Process
The nonparticipating provider submits its claim to the carrier within 60 days after the service. The carrier pays within 60 days of receiving the claim the greater of its negotiated median for the region and specialty or 150 percent of the Medicare fee schedule (MCL 333.24507). The parties may agree to a higher amount (MCL 333.24513).
Federal Process
Outside the state law, the federal sequence applies: open negotiation starts within 30 business days of the first payment or denial and lasts 30 business days.
Federal and state IDR procedure
State Dispute Forum
DIFS accepts FIS 2369 for negotiated-median amount calculation review and FIS 2368 for binding arbitration after a carrier denies an eligible emergency complicating-factor claim. Submit to DIFS-SurpriseBilling@michigan.gov or fax 517-763-0305; the calculation review is not itself arbitration.
Federal Dispute Forum
Claims outside the state law, such as air ambulance or non-opted self-funded plans, are filed in the CMS IDR Gateway.
Decision Model
If the carrier finds a complicating factor, it makes one additional payment of 25 percent of the median-negotiated amount (MCL 333.24511(2)). If it denies, the provider may request binding arbitration from DIFS and the parties agree on an arbitrator from the DIFS approved list. Each side pays half of the arbitration costs.
No Surprises Act and IDR deadlines
Confirm the trigger event and live rule before filing.
Provider claim to carrier
Within 60 days after the date of service (MCL 333.24507(2))
Carrier payment
Within 60 days after the carrier receives the claim (MCL 333.24507(4))
Carrier answer to a complicating-factor claim
Within 30 days after receiving the claim (MCL 333.24511(2))
Carrier response after DIFS accepts arbitration
Within 30 days after DIFS notifies the carrier (MCL 333.24511(4))
Arbitrator's written decision
Within 45 days after receiving the parties' documentation (MCL 333.24511(5))
Federal IDR for claims outside state law
Start within 4 business days after the 30-business-day negotiation ends
Documentation checklist
- DIFS form FIS 2369 (Request for Review of Calculation of Charges)
- DIFS form FIS 2368 (Request for Binding Arbitration)
- Clinical documentation and the highlighted medical record showing the complicating factor
- The carrier's denial letter and contact details for the patient's health benefit plan
- Plan-type evidence from the ID card to confirm state or federal route
Responsible agencies
- Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS)Surprise medical billing calculation reviews, arbitration and consumer complaints
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (Federal IDR)Federal payment disputes and enforcement backstop
Primary recovery and regulatory sources
- DIFS: Surprise Medical BillingMichigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services · 2026
- MCL 333.24511, complicating-factor claims and binding arbitrationMichigan Legislature
- MCL 333.24507, nonparticipating provider payment in fullMichigan Legislature
- CMS revised Michigan No Surprises Act enforcement and dispute-resolution letterCMS / CCIIO · 2023-07-20
- CMS applicability chart, federal versus bifurcated statesCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services
- MCL 333.24513, agreement to a higher payment amountMichigan Legislature
This operational reference is educational, is not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.