Good Faith Estimates for uninsured and self-pay patients have been required since 2022. Our Good Faith Estimate workflow guide covers creating them. This article focuses on what happens when the bill exceeds the estimate, and the front-office habits that prevent disputes.

When an estimate is due

SituationDeadline to provide the estimate
Service scheduled at least 10 business days aheadWithin 3 business days of scheduling
Service scheduled 3 to 9 business days aheadWithin 1 business day of scheduling
Patient asks for an estimate without schedulingWithin 3 business days of the request

Estimates must be written, on paper or electronically. A phone quote does not satisfy the rule. Estimates for insured patients and plan advanced explanations of benefits have not been implemented; check CMS for current status before changing workflows.

How the $400 threshold works

  • The comparison is made separately for each provider or facility on the estimate, not for the total.
  • A provider whose bill is $400 or more above its own estimated amount can face a dispute, even if the total bill is close to the total estimate.
  • Items or services not on the estimate can also be disputed.
  • The patient starts the dispute within 120 calendar days of receiving the initial bill.

What happens during a dispute

  1. The patient pays a $25 administrative fee and submits the estimate and the bill.
  2. The provider must not move the bill to collections while the dispute is pending, and must pause late fees.
  3. A selected dispute resolution entity reviews whether the higher charges were justified by medically necessary items or services that could not reasonably have been anticipated.
  4. If the entity decides an amount lower than the bill, the provider's charge is limited and the patient's $25 fee is credited.

Front-office checklist

  • Identify uninsured and self-pay patients at scheduling.
  • Provide written estimates within the deadlines above, and coordinate co-provider charges where your organization does so.
  • Include the required disclaimers, including the patient's right to dispute.
  • Update the estimate if the scheduled services change.
  • Keep estimates and supporting records for at least six years.
  • Flag any final bill that is $400 or more above a provider's estimated amount before it is sent.

Front-office discipline also supports insured out-of-network workflows; see our ancillary services guide for notice and consent.

Coordinating co-provider estimates

Care for uninsured and self-pay patients often involves more than one provider or facility, such as a surgeon, an anesthesiologist and a facility. The rules contemplate a convening provider or facility coordinating an estimate that includes co-provider and co-facility charges, but CMS has deferred enforcement of the co-provider requirement pending further rulemaking. Many organizations still coordinate co-provider charges voluntarily, because a fuller estimate reduces the risk of a bill exceeding it; agree in advance who sends what and by when.

When a patient starts a dispute

  1. Stop collection activity on the disputed bill and pause late fees.
  2. Gather the estimate, the bill and the clinical documentation for the difference.
  3. Prepare a short explanation of any medically necessary items or services that could not reasonably have been anticipated.
  4. Respond to the dispute resolution entity within its deadlines.
  5. Apply the outcome to the bill and credit the patient's fee where required.

Training the front desk

  • Ask every patient scheduling a service whether they will use insurance.
  • Explain the estimate in plain language and how to request one.
  • Never give phone-only quotes in place of a written estimate.
  • Escalate unusual or complex cases to a billing lead.

Common causes of disputes

  • Estimates missing a co-provider's charges.
  • Services added on the day without an updated estimate.
  • Charges for supplies or drugs not listed on the estimate.
  • Late estimates that left patients unable to plan.
Official Government Authority
Good Faith Estimates and Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution
Authority: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)
Official Government Authority
45 C.F.R. §149.620 — Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution
Authority: Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
Visit Official Portal (opens in a new tab)

Frequently Addressed Procedural Questions

Who can use patient-provider dispute resolution?
Uninsured patients and self-pay patients who received a Good Faith Estimate and whose bill from a provider or facility is at least $400 more than that provider's estimated amount.
How long does a patient have to start a dispute?
120 calendar days from the date the initial bill was received.
Can we send the bill to collections during a dispute?
No. The bill must not be moved to collections while the dispute is pending, and late fees must be paused.
Are Good Faith Estimates required for insured patients yet?
The requirements for insured patients and plan advanced explanations of benefits have not been implemented. Check CMS for current status.
Who prepares the estimate when several providers are involved?
The convening provider or facility prepares it. Including co-provider and co-facility charges is part of the rule, but CMS has deferred enforcement of that piece pending further rulemaking; check CMS for current status.
Can a provider bill above the estimate at all?
Yes, but if the bill is $400 or more above the provider's estimated amount, the patient may dispute it, and the provider should be able to show why the difference was necessary and unforeseeable.