Batching is where the economics of Federal IDR improve and where many disputes fail eligibility. Our batching decision guide covers when to batch. This article focuses on the definitions that cause the most errors: what counts as a batch, what counts as a bundle, and how the line-item cap works.
Batched and bundled are different things
| Batched dispute | Bundled dispute | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Multiple qualified items or services grouped into one dispute | One payment that covers several items or services for one patient |
| Typical example | Several patients' head CT scans from the same provider and plan | A single payment rate that covers a package of services, such as a diagnosis-related group |
| How it is valued | The entity decides each line | The entity decides the single bundled payment |
| Main risk | Mixing items that do not meet the batching criteria | Calling something a bundle when the plan actually paid the lines separately |
The final rule defined a bundled payment arrangement for IDR purposes, and that definition applied from August 3, 2026. A claim is a bundle only when the plan pays one amount for the group of services. If the plan paid line by line, the lines must be disputed as individual items or as a batch.
The batching gates
Every item in a batch must meet each of these conditions. If any line fails one, it should be filed separately or in a different batch.
- Same provider or facility. The items were billed by the same provider, facility or air ambulance provider, identified consistently in the dispute.
- Same plan. The items are payable by the same group health plan or health insurance issuer. Separate self-funded employer plans administered by the same third-party administrator are not the same plan.
- Similar items or services. The items meet one of the similarity criteria in CMS's guidance, such as the same or comparable service code, or for anesthesiology, radiology, pathology and laboratory services, codes within the same CPT code range group.
- Timing. The items were furnished within the period the rules allow for a single batch.
- Size. For disputes whose open negotiation began on or after November 1, 2026, the batch holds no more than 50 line items.
CPT code ranges for hospital-based specialties
CMS's October 2026 guidance lists code-range groups that may be batched for anesthesiology, radiology, pathology and laboratory services furnished to one or more patients. Radiology has 27 range groups covering diagnostic imaging, ultrasound, radiologic guidance, mammography, bone and joint studies, radiation oncology and nuclear medicine. A batch may combine codes only from the same range group. For example, head and neck imaging can be batched with other codes in that range, but not with pelvic imaging or mammography.
A five-step pre-filing batch audit
- Confirm every line shares the same provider identifiers and the same plan, using plan-level information rather than the TPA name.
- Confirm every line meets one similarity criterion, and for code-range batches, that all codes sit in one range group.
- Confirm dates of service fall within the allowed period and that no line is inside a cooling-off period.
- Count lines without modifiers; stop at 50.
- Decide bundle or batch from how the plan actually paid, using the remittance.
Cooling-off periods for batches
Under the final rule, a determination on a batched dispute triggers a 30-business-day cooling-off period instead of the 90 calendar days that apply to single disputes. Run separate calendars for single and batched determinations; our deadline guide explains how claims caught in a cooling-off period remain recoverable.
Why this matters more in 2027
CMS's implementation timeline indicates that the flexibility to resubmit improperly batched or bundled disputes will end once the related provisions are activated. Treat every batch as if it cannot be refiled: scrub it before submission. Specialty-specific guidance is in our articles on emergency medicine and radiology and anesthesiology and pathology.
A worked example
A radiology group reads CT scans for four patients injured in separate motor vehicle accidents, all covered by the same fully insured plan, all out of network, and all paid at the QPA. Each patient had head and neck imaging. Because the services were furnished by the same group, are payable by the same plan, fall within one radiology code-range group and were furnished within the allowed period, they can be batched. A fifth patient's lumbar spine CT for the same plan belongs in a different range group and needs its own batch or dispute. CMS's guidance includes a similar multi-patient radiology example.
Batch documentation template
| Field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Batch criterion | Same code, comparable code, or code-range group, with the group name |
| Plan identification | Plan or issuer name and identifiers, not just the TPA |
| Provider identification | The billing provider or facility identifiers used on every line |
| Date range | First and last date of service in the batch |
| Line count | Number of lines, excluding modifiers |
| Cooling-off check | Date checked and result for this party pair |
Common batching errors
- Batching by payer brand when the claims belong to different employer plans.
- Mixing code-range groups in a multi-patient radiology, anesthesiology or laboratory batch.
- Counting modifiers as lines and splitting batches unnecessarily, or entering add-on codes as separate lines and exceeding the cap.
- Treating separately paid lines as a bundle.
- Including a line from inside a cooling-off period.
